MTV Video Music Award (für Fallin')

2002

Grammy
- Best New Artist
- Best R&B Album (für Songs in A Minor)
- Song Of The Year (für Fallin')
- Best R&B Song (für Fallin')
- Best Female R&B Vocal Performance (für Fallin')

World Music Award
- Best-Selling New Artist
- World's Best-Selling Female R&B-Artist

MTV Europe Music Award (Best R&B Artist)

Echo (Bester Newcomer)

2004

Soul Train Award
- Best Female R&B/Soul Album (für The Diary of Alicia Keys)
- Best Female R&B/Soul Single (für If I Ain't Got You)
- Best R&B/Soul Single By A Group, Band Or Duo (für My Boo mit Usher)

Billboard Award
Female Artist of the Year
Female R&B/Hip Hop Artist of the Year
R&B/Hip Hop Singles Artist of the Year
R&B/Hip Hop Single of the Year (für If I Ain't Got You)
Hot 100 Songwriter of the Year
Female Hot 100 Artist of the Year
R&B/Hip Hop Airplay Single of the Year (für If I Ain't Got You)

American Music Award (Favorite Female Artist)

World Music Award (Best R&B Female Artist)

MTV Video Music Award (Best R&B Video und Best R&B Artist)

2005

Grammy
- Best R&B Album (für The Diary Of Alicia Keys)
- Best Traditional R&B Vocal Performance (für You Don't Know My Name)
- Best Female R&B Vocal Performance (für If I Ain't Got You)
- Best R&B Vocal Performance by A Group, Band Or Do (für My Boo)

MTV Video Music Award (Best R&B Video: Karma)

MTV Europe Music Award (Best R&B Artist)

RIAA Awards
- Songs In A Minor – 6-fach-Platin (7. November 2003)
- The Diary of Alicia Keys - 3-fach-Platin (24. Mai 2004)

2008

Grammy
- Best female R'n'B Vocal performance (für ''No One'')
- Best R'n'B Song (für ''No One'')
Black Entertainment Television [BET] Award
- Beste Sängerin